I have a Catto 3 blade on my RV8, IO360. But I don't have anything to compare it to, as it's the only RV I've ever flown. I make about 2100-2150 RPM on takeoff, and flat out at 6500' it winds up to 2750 RPM. It might go 50 RPM higher but I don't let it. I cruise it about 2550 and ROP about 170 KTS true.
I did a little formation work with some Extra 300s, and they can out-accelerate me, but otherwise a pretty good match.
I like the idea of simplicity, light weight, and good CG characteristics, but I like to do aerobatics and I sometimes wish I had CS prop (and inverted oil, and smoke, etc. but I digress).
I did alot of searches on here about how to figure out power settings, etc. because I haven't flown behind a fixed pitch prop in many years. Also the guy who ferried the airplane for me was concerned with the low takeoff RPM. But it's a 66" prop and takes a big bite, and seems in line with what most other Catto pilots are seeing.